{"reviews":{"source":{"verdict":"pass","summary":"Automated source-support review found no material issue across the complete prose, table, equations, code comments, answers and claim ledger. Live primary-source passages and version histories support the citations. The saved discovery excerpt was read through ResearchNode and provides no additional corroboration. Calculations agree with the supplied isolated execution record; this review did not execute Python or validate a detector. No diagrams or private material were supplied.","issues":[],"claims":[{"id":"C1","verdict":"supported","reason":"[S1 abstract and introduction](https://arxiv.org/html/1610.05820v2) define supplied-record membership inference and demonstrate prediction-output attacks within studied settings."},{"id":"C2","verdict":"supported","reason":"[S1 introduction](https://arxiv.org/html/1610.05820v2) explicitly describes known-membership shadow datasets and training an attack model from shadow-model inputs and outputs."},{"id":"C3","verdict":"supported","reason":"[S2 Section III-B](https://arxiv.org/html/2112.03570v2) recommends TPR at low FPR and full logarithmic ROC curves, explaining aggregate accuracy's limitations."},{"id":"C4","verdict":"supported","reason":"The supplied content and asset contain synthetic arithmetic, with no personal records, model queries or implemented detector. The stated inference limits match that scope."},{"id":"C5","verdict":"supported","reason":"Experimental choices are explicitly proposed assumptions, not reported measurements. Record/person distinctions and separating threshold selection from assessment are logically justified."},{"id":"C6","verdict":"supported","reason":"Confusion-count identities and all rate denominators are correct, including the distinction between FPR and the false-positive fraction among positive predictions."},{"id":"C7","verdict":"supported","reason":"All constructed counts, rounded precision and accuracy values, and the 99% always-negative baseline are correct. The table, prose, code and answers agree."},{"id":"C8","verdict":"supported","reason":"The population precision identity and conditional ceiling f ≤ 1/1485 are correct. Transfer assumptions, finite-sample limitations and threshold feasibility are explicitly qualified."},{"id":"C9","verdict":"supported","reason":"Code inspection supports the arithmetic-only description and input assumptions. The supplied execution record confirms the synthetic outputs; neither it nor the assertions validate a membership detector."},{"id":"C10","verdict":"supported","reason":"FPR count increments are correct, and 0.999^100 = 0.904792… supports 90.48%. Independence and common error probability are stated; no confidence interval is claimed."},{"id":"C11","verdict":"supported","reason":"The distinction between assessed counts and conditional projections follows from the example. A single detector's failure logically cannot establish universal privacy."},{"id":"C12","verdict":"supported","reason":"Declared source passages match their scope. Submission histories confirm [S1's 2017-03-31 v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/1610.05820) and [S2's 2022-04-12 v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.03570). ResearchNode returned the stated discovery revision. Historical author actions remain explicitly self-reported, not independently authenticated."}],"package_sha256":"04cb9b1777296baac81ff13f0414d3b450b8c7d0d4ae98b15eba76f896e4e4e6","reviewed_at":"2026-11-15T09:08:31.275082+01:00"},"visual":{"verdict":"pass","summary":"Reviewed all 44 rendered screenshots in the supplied manifest against the five style references and notebook content. Desktop, both mobile widths, scroll-panel positions and all six print pages show no material visual or visible semantic issues. Dark styling, syntax colours, rounded question rows, badges and numbered full-URL references are consistent. Dense content scrolls within panels; print preserves the table, code and answers. No diagram is needed. Recorded browser checks report successful keyboard navigation, scrolling and downloads; these were not independently rerun. This review does not certify factual accuracy.","issues":[],"claims":[],"package_sha256":"04cb9b1777296baac81ff13f0414d3b450b8c7d0d4ae98b15eba76f896e4e4e6","reviewed_at":"2026-11-15T09:08:31.275095+01:00"}},"checks":{"package_sha256":"04cb9b1777296baac81ff13f0414d3b450b8c7d0d4ae98b15eba76f896e4e4e6","passed":true,"widths":[1440,390,320],"code_checked":true,"code":[{"language":"python","syntax":"passed","sha256":"94c73f4f48afb6d3112d5389b2a5e7fa8b2739fa4cec574662d41391fd688b2f"}],"execution":[{"file":"lab.py","sha256":"94c73f4f48afb6d3112d5389b2a5e7fa8b2739fa4cec574662d41391fd688b2f","returncode":0,"output":"members=1000, nonmembers=1000\nTP=600, FP=10, FN=400, TN=990\nprecision=98.36%\naccuracy=79.50%\nmembers=1000, nonmembers=99000\nTP=600, FP=990, FN=400, TN=98010\nprecision=37.74%\naccuracy=98.61%\nconditional FPR ceiling=0.06734%\n","environment":"CPython 3.12 isolated container; no network, no host mounts; 128 MiB; 1 CPU"}],"drawio":[],"print":"rendered"},"published_at":"2026-11-15T08:08:31.739Z"}